match use of cards, i would give a 2, 3 ABSOLUTE MAX, he used the deck very poorly.
number of cards, you asked me how many he had, i'm hopeing you actually checked with him, you need to start taking care of shit during the duel.
he didn't catch worm king mess up you should have taken off for focus in the single.
you cannot give points for the side deck when you don't even know if they had one which you stated you did not in siding.
also if you misplayed ONCE and he didn't catch it, its not half his ruling gone?
you need to improve on these things, you graded poorly. while there are no testers its our jobs to test, i need people who can test correctly.